Seven years later, and the conversation is back.
At the PGA TOUR stop in South Carolina this week, the early scenes at the RBC Heritage felt familiar. Practice rounds were filled with players in shorts. Nearly the entire field, in fact. Lightweight fabrics, shorter inseams, a clear nod to heat and humidity.
Then Thursday arrived.
And just like that, the uniform shifted back to pants.
The Rule Has Not Moved
It is a contrast the TOUR has been living with since February 2019, when players were first allowed to wear shorts during practice rounds and pro ams
The structure is simple
Practice rounds and pro ams allow shorts
Competition rounds require pants
No exceptions. No weather based flexibility.
It is one of the clearest lines the TOUR still draws when it comes to presentation. In a sport that has embraced performance fabrics, relaxed fits, and even a broader range of footwear, this is one rule that has stayed exactly where it started.
Players Have Mostly Stayed In The Middle
What is interesting is how little pushback there has been publicly.
Players like Justin Thomas and Rory McIlroy have acknowledged the obvious. It gets hot. Conditions can be brutal. But modern pants are lighter, more breathable, and built for exactly this environment.
At the same time, there is still an understanding of what the uniform represents. Tradition matters. The look matters.
So the conversation from players tends to land in the same place. Not a demand for change, but an openness to what it could look like if it ever came.
The LPGA Has Already Answered This
Over on the LPGA Tour, the conversation feels a lot more settled.
Shorts, pants, skirts, and skorts are all part of the rotation. Players move between them without it feeling disruptive or out of place. The product still feels professional. The presentation still holds.
If anything, it has expanded what a modern golf uniform can look like.
Which makes the contrast on the men’s side even more noticeable.
The Internet Is Split And Then Some
When the question came up again this week, the response was immediate. And all over the place.
Some fans went straight to practicality
“Outdoor sport and it’s hot. Dress for the weather.”
“They should be allowed to dress for the weather… it’s not that hard.”
Others stayed rooted in tradition
“No. It’s an honor to wear pants.”
“Pants are the uniform.”
“Pros wear pants. End of story.”
And then there is the middle ground, which might be the most telling
“I’d be cool with shorts for regular Tour events but pants for majors.”
“Just make it weather dependent.”
“Shorts for practice rounds ok Thursday to Sunday pants only.”
Of course, the internet being the internet had its moments too
“Give. Me. Leg.”
“A don doesn’t wear shorts.”
It is funny, but it also says a lot. Because this is not just a dress code discussion. It is about how people see the game.
Two Versions Of The Same Tour
What makes this interesting is that the TOUR already lives in both worlds.
Early in the week, it looks like any high level round in the summer. Players in shorts, moving comfortably, dressing for the conditions.
By Thursday, it shifts back to something more structured. More uniform. More in line with how the game has always presented itself at the highest level.
That split has worked. But it also keeps the question alive.
Where This Could Go
So maybe the future is not about removing the rule. Maybe it is about adjusting it.
Pants still preferred. Tradition still intact. But shorts existing as an option in the right moments.
Because what we are seeing now is a TOUR that already operates in two modes. One built around comfort and conditions. The other built around uniform and tradition.
The only thing left to figure out is whether those two ideas can meet somewhere in the middle, or if the line stays exactly where it is.
Our Latest Favorites in the Shorts Vs Pants Debate
